AH Media
AH Media
A Rebrand, Two Domains, and the Traffic That Went Missing
Case Observations

A Rebrand, Two Domains, and the Traffic That Went Missing

By Alex Hayes ·

Two accounting practices merge, a new name goes on the door, and six months later the partners are asking why the phone rings less than it used to. The website was rebuilt, the branding is sharp, and nothing obvious is broken. What went missing was the connective tissue between several hundred old URLs and their replacements, and nobody was watching the part of the project where that happens.

What Actually Happens When Two Practices Become One

WLTM: The importance of meeting rooms in business - Serviced Office Company

The Merger Comes First, the Website Comes Last

By the time anyone asks what happens to the two websites, the merger has been running for months. The agreement is signed, the practice management software is chosen, and the letterhead is at the printer. The website appears on the list somewhere below the phone system.

That order produces the same result every time. The web work gets a fortnight, a small budget, and a brief that amounts to make it look like the new brand. Nobody has budgeted for the part that matters: deciding what happens to several hundred existing URLs that people and search engines have used for years.

The rebrand is a marketing project with a deadline. The migration is a technical project with dependencies. Treating them as one job is where the trouble starts.

Two Domains, One New Name, One Launch Date

It usually goes like this. Two firms, each with a domain live for a decade or more, each carrying links from business directories, a chamber of commerce, and sponsorship pages. The merged firm picks a new name, registers a new domain, and wants both old sites pointing at it the morning the new signage goes up.

The instinct is understandable. Two live sites carrying dead brands is a mess, and clients notice. But the domains are not equivalent, and treating them as a matched pair is the first mistake. One almost always carries more of the firm's search visibility than the other, and it is not always the larger practice. The smaller firm whose owner wrote a monthly article for eight years can easily be the one holding the traffic.

Before anything is switched off, somebody needs to know which domain carries what.

The Redirect Map Is the Whole Job

Why the Blanket Homepage Redirect Fails

The default approach, the one requiring no thought at all, points every URL on both old domains at the new homepage. One rule in the server configuration, five minutes of work, every old link resolving to something. It looks tidy.

What it does is discard the specificity of every one of those links. A page about provisional tax that ranked for years, linked from a small business forum, now drops the visitor on a homepage that says nothing about provisional tax. Google's own documentation on moving a site with URL changes is explicit that each old address should point at its closest equivalent rather than at the root.

The visitor outcome is worse than the search outcome. Someone clicks expecting an answer to a specific question and lands on a brand statement. They leave. That is an enquiry that never happens, and nothing in the analytics will tell you it was ever there.

Mapping Page to Page, Including the Awkward Ones

The work is unglamorous and it is not optional. Export every URL from both old sites - sitemaps, server logs, analytics, backlink data if you have it. You will end up with several hundred rows, most worthless, a few dozen carrying everything.

Sort by inbound links and by entry traffic over the past year, then work down the list. Each row gets a destination on the new site. The top fifty take real thought. The rest can usually be handled with pattern rules, provided somebody has checked they hold.

The awkward rows are where the two firms overlap. Both old sites had a page on business structures. Both ranked. The new site has one. Two old addresses now point at one destination, which is fine, but somebody has to decide which piece of content survives, or whether the replacement is written from the better parts of both. That decision is editorial, not technical, and it needs a person who has read both pages.

The Pages With Nowhere to Go

Some pages have nowhere to go. A service one firm offered and the merged practice does not. A post about an office move in 2016. An event page for a seminar series that ended.

The temptation is to send them all to the homepage, which puts us back where we started, or to let them 404, wasting whatever links they carry. Neither works as a blanket rule.

My test is whether anything points at the page. If it does - a directory, an industry body, a local news site - it earns a redirect to the nearest related page, even where the fit is loose. A discontinued audit service page can reasonably land on assurance services. If nothing points at it and nobody has visited in a year, let it go.

The mistake is not choosing wrong on a single page. It is not choosing at all.

The Trail Nobody Updates

Meeting spaces in the modern office | Kinnarps

Directories, Registers and Professional Listings

Redirects handle the links you cannot control. They do nothing about the references you can.

A New Zealand financial services firm accumulates an unusual number of listings:

- the professional body directory and the financial service providers register
- the Companies Office record and the firm's NZBN entry
- the local chamber and two or three regional business directories
- a sponsorship page on a school or sports club site

Every one carries the old name, the old domain, and often an old phone number. A few update themselves when the underlying registration changes. Most do not, and several need an email to a person who checks that inbox weekly.

None of this is technically difficult. It is a list, some emails, and a fortnight of attention spread over two months. What I see instead is a list nobody owns, and eighteen months later the old domain is still on a school newsletter's sponsor page.

Google Business Profile and the Two-Office Problem

Google Business Profile deserves separate treatment, because it is where the merger's untidiness becomes visible to the public.

Two firms means two profiles, each with its own reviews, photos, and local search presence. If the merged firm keeps both offices, both stay, and both need renaming and re-linking to the new site. If it consolidates to one office, the other has to be closed or marked as moved, and reviews sitting on a deleted profile do not come across.

That is worth pausing on, because review history at a professional services firm is not decoration. It is often the only third-party signal a prospective client sees before picking up the phone, and losing a decade of it is permanent.

The pattern I see most often is neither profile touched for months, both pointing at dead domains, both carrying the old names, while the firm wonders why the phone is quieter.

The Pages That Quietly Disappear

Staff Profiles Are Search Entry Points

Here is the loss nobody predicts and everybody feels.

At most established firms, a meaningful share of site entries come from someone searching a named individual. A referral says talk to the person who handles trusts, the prospective client searches the name, and the old site had a profile page for that person: name in the address, photo, background, direct line.

The new merged site has a team page with twelve headshots in a grid and no individual pages, because the designer preferred the look and nobody framed it as a traffic question.

That is a whole category of qualified visitor switched off, and the kind that converts better than anything else, because the searcher already has a name and an intention. They are not comparing firms. They are trying to find a phone number.

If both old sites had individual profiles, the new one needs them, at stable addresses, redirected person by person. Where somebody has left, send their page to the colleague who inherited their clients.

Service Pages Collapsed Into One

The other quiet loss is consolidation for its own sake.

Two firms bring two sets of service pages. One had separate pages for rental property tax, trust administration, and business valuations. The other had a single services page covering everything. The merged site, built to look uncluttered, ends up with four broad pages and a lot of white space.

Those specific pages were doing work. Someone searching for help with rental property tax landed on a page about exactly that, written by someone who does it. Now they land on a tax services page that mentions it in a bullet point, if at all.

More pages is not always better, and thin pages built to chase keywords are their own problem. But a page that was ranking, converting and specific is not clutter. Folding it into a paragraph is a decision with a cost, and it deserves to be made deliberately rather than as a side effect of a redesign.

The Shape of the Recovery

Modern Conference Room Decor Ideas to refresh your office | Smartway2

What the First Few Months Look Like

Even a well-executed migration drops. Worth saying plainly, because the firms I have watched go through this were not warned, and the fall arrived looking like a fault rather than a phase.

The shape is consistent. Traffic falls in the days after the switchover as search engines re-crawl and reassess. It sits near the bottom for a while. Then it climbs back unevenly, over months rather than weeks, with some pages returning quickly, some lagging, and a residue that never returns.

A migration done properly recovers faster and lands closer to where it started. One done with a blanket redirect and no directory work sits in the trough far longer, and the firm often cannot tell how far below the old baseline it has settled, because nobody recorded the baseline.

That part is entirely avoidable. Export the numbers from both old properties before the switchover.

The Sequence That Makes It Easier

None of this needs a large budget. It needs the work done in a sensible order, and it needs somebody to own it.

Measure first, before either old site is touched. Build the redirect map while both are still live and readable. Launch on the new domain and let it settle briefly before the old domains are redirected, so problems surface while a fallback still exists. Then redirect, start the directory and profile work, and keep reading the redirect log for a couple of months, because there will be addresses nobody thought of.

If an agency is quoting for a merger site, one question separates those who have done this from those who have not. Ask how they are handling the redirect map, and ask to see it. One that has done it before will have a spreadsheet. One that has not will talk about the design.

A rebrand is visible. Every partner sees the new logo, the new site, the new signage. The migration underneath it is invisible until it fails, which is why it gets the smallest share of the attention and causes the largest share of the damage. The firms that come through this well are not the ones with the best design; they are the ones where somebody kept a spreadsheet.

The Briefing

Digital strategy analysis for NZ financial professionals. No jargon, no upsells, no SEO promises -- just the insights Alex would give you over coffee if you had the meeting.